Choosing the right type of app for your business can be challenging, especially with the variety of options available—Progressive Web Apps vs. Web Apps vs. Mobile Apps. Each option offers unique benefits and use cases, but knowing when to choose one over the other can make a significant difference in cost, performance, and user satisfaction.
In this article, we’ll break down the differences, explore their pros and cons, and help you decide the best solution for your business goals.
What Are the Differences?
| Feature | Web App | Progressive Web App (PWA) | Mobile App |
|---|---|---|---|
| Platform | Runs in a web browser | Runs in a web browser, can be installed | Built for iOS/Android platforms |
| Installation | Not installable | Installable without an app store | Downloaded via app stores |
| Offline Functionality | No | Yes (via caching) | Yes (fully functional offline) |
| Access to Device Features | Limited | Some (e.g., push notifications, GPS) | Full access (camera, sensors, etc.) |
| Performance | Moderate (network-dependent) | High (optimized for speed) | Highest (platform-optimized) |
| Cost | Low | Moderate | High |
| Development Time | Short | Moderate | Long |
A web app is a browser-based application that works across devices without requiring installation. It’s lightweight, cost-effective, and ideal for basic functionality.
When to Choose a Web App:
- When you need a simple, fast solution for internal tools or basic services.
- When your audience primarily uses desktops or laptops.
- When cost efficiency is a priority.
Learn more about the benefits of web apps here.
A PWA combines the best of web and mobile apps. It runs in a browser but can also be installed on a device, offering offline functionality and push notifications.
When to Choose a PWA:
- When you need to reach a broad audience on both desktop and mobile.
- When you want an app-like experience without the cost of developing separate native apps.
- When speed and accessibility are priorities, e.g., e-commerce platforms or content-based sites.
See real-world examples of successful PWAs like Twitter Lite here.
A mobile app is a platform-specific application built for iOS, Android, or both. It’s downloaded from app stores and offers the best performance, full access to device features, and advanced capabilities.
When to Choose a Mobile App:
- When your app requires complex functionalities, such as AR/VR, advanced graphics, or hardware integrations.
- When you’re targeting a highly engaged audience who will benefit from push notifications, offline access, and a polished user experience.
- When your app is central to your business model, such as ride-hailing apps (e.g., Grab) or gaming platforms.
| Development Type | Cost Range (MYR) | Time to Develop (Months) | Use Case Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Web App | 25,000 - 65,000 | 1-3 | Internal management tools |
| Progressive Web App | 50,000 - 150,000 | 2-5 | E-commerce, online services |
| Mobile App | 150,000 - ... | 4-12 | Gaming, social platforms |
1. Audience
Progressive Web Apps vs. Web Apps vs. Mobile Apps should be evaluated based on your target users.
- If your target users span multiple devices (desktop and mobile), a PWA or web app is ideal.
- If your audience primarily uses smartphones, especially on iOS or Android, a mobile app is the way to go.
2. Budget
- If your budget is limited, opt for a web app or PWA for a cost-effective solution.
- If you have the resources and need a premium experience, invest in a mobile app.
3. Functionality
- Choose a mobile app for advanced features like AR/VR, complex animations, or heavy data processing.
- Select a PWA for push notifications, offline access, and speed.
- Use a web app for basic functionalities like form submissions or content delivery.
4. Long-Term Goals
- PWAs are scalable and offer great ROI for growing businesses.
- Mobile apps work well for established brands seeking a robust, dedicated platform.
PWAs have emerged as a middle ground between web apps and mobile apps, offering many of the advantages of both. Businesses like Starbucks and Twitter have successfully used PWAs to provide fast, reliable, and engaging user experiences while minimizing development costs.
At Black Dash Interactive Design, we specialise in crafting custom web apps, progressive web apps, and mobile apps that align with your business needs. Whether you’re looking for a lightweight solution or a feature-rich mobile app, our team can help you:
- Assess the best option based on your goals, budget, and audience.
- Build scalable and high-performing apps tailored to your unique requirements.
- Stay ahead of trends with cutting-edge technologies like PWAs.
